Disclaimer: this page represents my attempt to synthesize various sources of information about eukaryotic phylogeny. It is not intended to be taken as a "system" of taxonomic or phylogenetic organization, and it certainly should not be taken as the "true" phylogeny. It is merely what I am currently inclined to believe, a convenient scheme upon which to tack other pieces of information. Please let me know if I am missing anything that you feel ought to be on here, or if you find anything that you disagree with or that you know to be wrong. Thanks!
Earthly Life/Eukaryota
Eukaryota
Origin ~2.5 BYA: Runnegar 1995; 2.4-2.8 BYA: Knoll 1992; ~1.5 BYA: C-S 1993; ~2 BYA: Doolittle MBL 10-97.
A conservative/cynical rendition of the eukaryotic tree would be an unresolved star consisting of those taxa in bold type.
4-01-98: Based mostly on tubulin sequence data, Patrick Keeling proposes that there are four basic euk groups -- Diplomonads, Parabasalia, Animals+Fungi, and Everything Else.
6-02-98: I think his work on enolases is beginning to show a similar picture, though it's too early to really tell. IBC 1999: two enolase gap characters group the parabasalia with eubacteria and archaes to the exclusion of all other euks.
1999 IBC: Patrick is now suggesting the following euk tree: (parabasalia, (A+C+F, metamonads, (stramenopiles, alveolates, red+green+glaucocysto, others)))
1998 SMBE: Patterson estimates that there are 70-plus protistan groups "equivalent" (in age? uniqueness?) to animals, plants, and fungi. These 70 groups make up 95% of euk diversity, but less than 10% of species.
June 1998: The weight of the data now push me to abolish any listing of Archaezoa -- I simply don't believe that there is any reason to think that any extant euks were primitively amitochondriate, and that is the main basis of Archaezoa as a taxon. From amongst the profusion of euk-origin theories, I am inclined to believe some fusion (!) of Ford Doolittle's "you are what you eat" and Martin/Muller's Hydrogen hypotheses as explaining the euk genes that show affinities to Archaebacteria, gram-positive bacteria, and alpha-proteobacteria.
As noted above, especially as of MBL 10-97, it seems the concensus guess is that all extant euks are descended from mitochondriate ancestors. Possible exceptions are retortamonads and oxymonads.
1999 IBC: Martin Embley points out that although there are multiple euk lineages with hydrogenosomes, they are scattered amongst aerobic taxa, suggesting likely mutiple origins. Analysis of Pyruvate ferrodoxin oxidoreductase and hydrogenase suggest monophyly, but no grouping with alpha or delta proteos. Thus either all hydrogenosomes are monophyletic or they have (apparently) gotten their machinery (in part) from the same source. Perhaps by diet ala Ford Doolittle's "you are what you eat"? Also, he says that hydrogenosomes are often accompanied by (intracellular) symbiotic assemblages of methanogenic archaes and sometimes ALSO eubacteria! Very cool.
July 2002: Stechmann and C-S report in Science a DHFR/Thymidilate Synthase fusion gene shared by bikonts (ancestrally biflagellate euks, essentially all euks except Ophistokonta [A+F+choanoflagellates] and, maybe, amoebozoa); as this fusion is assumed to be derived (eubacteria have separate genes), that makes the ophistokonts the deepest eukaryote branch! So much for a crown...
Metamonads
(Based largely on what was and wasn't said at MBL 10-97.)
C-S lumps Retortamonads+Oxymonads with Giardia&co., but Patterson suggests they are separate, potentially primitively amitochondriate. He also says that Jakobids are near relatives, though they clearly have mitos.
As reported at IBC 1999, OGMP trees do not put Jakobids detectably deeper in mitochondriate euks than any other group.
2-98 P. Keeling: Metamonads = Diplomonads + Retortamonds; these share tetrakont flagella/basal bodies. Jakobids may not belong here as SSU puts them at base of crown. Sogin&co. currently doing multigene diplo/retorta/Jakobid analysis (with tuf/gapdh/tubulin/cpn60?)
- Oxymonads (no data yet on mito-origin genes)
- Dinenympha (endosymbiont of termite hindgut -- see gbk AB007028)
- Retortamonads & relatives (tetrakont flagellates that look essentially like 1/2 of a diplomonad; no data yet on mito-origin genes; SMBE 1998: Sogin showed SSU rRNA data that place retortamonads in basal multichotomy on tree-of-life with parabasalia, diplomonads, and microsporidia)
- Chilomastix
- Trimastix (sister to the retortamonads)
- Carpediomonas (related to Chilomastix and the Jakobids?)
- Diplomonads (Andrew Roger/Graham Clarke/Mitch Sogin have found mito-like hsp60 in Giardia, suggesting secondary loss of mito; note also that at 1998 SMBE Sogin indicated that Giardia genome contains spliceosome components, at least by BLAST...)
- Jakobids (=histionids?; related to the retortamonads? 1998 SMBE: Sogin's SSU rRNA puts Jakobids at base of euk crown)
- Jakoba (only rpoBC in mtDNA so far: Gray MBL 10-97)
- Reclinomonas (rpoABCD in mtDNA: Gray MBL 10-97; huge and gene-rich mtDNA: Lang 1997 Nature 387:493)
- Malawimonas (no rpo in mtDNA: Gray MBL 10-97)
Parabasalia
(amitochondriate, but have hydrogenosome: C-S Evol of Cells 1991; hydrogenosome is probably a derived mito: Bui(1996)PNAS 93:9651; discoid cristae puts them in the Discicristata with Euglenozoa: C-S MBL 10-97 -- but note that Stechmann(2002)Science puts Parabasalia out of discicristata on branch with metamonda; tubulin trees are consistent with discicristata, and suggest a larger (discicristata+alveolate, maybe +plants) clade: P. Keeling, 2-98, and see Keeling and Doolittle 1996 MBE)
- Trichomonadea
- Hypermastigotes
- Barbulanympha, a roach hindgut endosymbiont (Peter Merrit 1996)
Everything else
This is essentially an expanded eukaryote "crown". The Crown is a tenuous concept, as taxa like Dictyostelium jump in and out of the crown, depending on the gene used, but there is still a consistent tendency of these taxa to form a more-or-less differentiated bush or radiation, so I am keeping the clade.
Origin and radiation ~1 BYR: Knoll 1992, but of course, if the crown is not a natural grp and all euks are mito'd, then really this grp dates nearly to the origin of euks!
Blair Hedges' land-invasion analysis (Science 2001) suggests A/F/P split about 1.6 BYA, fungal land invasion followed by diversification about 1.2 BYA, based on multi-protein clock analysis. This is much older than other estimates on most counts...
All taxa "above" euglenozoa have spliceosomal introns (JML 11-11-94). Jeff in 1997 thinks this may not be meaningful, but C-S still uses it as a defining character: MBL 10-97.
- Euglenozoa (have snRNA-mediated trans-splicing and U-evens: JML 11-11-94; discoid cristae puts them in the Discicristata with Percolozoa/Heterolobosea: C-S MBL 10-97; tubulin trees are consistent with discicristata, and suggest a larger (discicristata+alveolate, maybe +plants) clade: P. Keeling, 2-98, and see Keeling and Doolittle 1996 MBE)
- Euglenoids (secondary green plastid: JDP 10-13-94 Halifax notes)
- Euglena
- Astasia
- Rhabdomonas
- Kinetoplastids
- Heterolobosea (have mito but not golgi) = Percolozoa? (discoid cristae puts them in the Discicristata with Euglenozoa: C-S MBL 10-97; tubulin trees are consistent with discicristata, and suggest a larger (discicristata+alveolate, maybe +plants) clade: P. Keeling, 2-98, and see Keeling and Doolittle 1996 MBE)(Gertraude Berger at IBC 1999 reports that OGMP data place Naegleria at base of euks, but this is on a VERY long branch.)
- Naegleria (part of the Vahlkampfiidae?)
- Psalteriomonas (for placement, see Corliss 1994; secondary red plastid...?:JDP 10-13-94; no mito, no peroxisomes, has hydrogenosomes. SSU rDNA puts it here: Weekers (1997) J. Euk. Microbio)
- Alveolata (this name from Corliss [from Cavalier-Smith] and Sogin; tubular mitochondrial christae (like stramenopiles), alveoli=compartments just inside cell membrane?)
- Perkinsus (C-S MBL 10-97: should be in Dinozoa, but it is conventionally placed in Apicomplexa; Chuck Delwiche 1998 SMBE suggests that it is best put here, in a trichotomy)
- Apicomplexa (=Sporozoa) (breakdown from Morrison&Ellis 1997 MBE 14:428)
- Cryptosporidium
- Coccidia
- Hematozoa
- Plasmodium (secondary red plastid? Chuck's tufA analysis says more likely green)
- Piroplasms
- Dinoflagellates (secondary plastid; I originally had this down as red, but I think I'll back off on that (IBC 1999). Beverly Green&C-S's Heterocapsa plastid genes group at least some dinos with apicomplexan plastids on LONG branch which goes either with greens or reds, depending on the analysis. Note also that she says fully 50% of dinos are non-plastidic!)(This list is REALLY rough...)
- Peridinen-containing dinoflagellates (chlA+chlC+peridinen as carotenoid pigment; plastid genome consists of single-gene minicircles: Beverly Green 1999 IBC and July 1999 Nature)
- Amphodinium
- Gonyalux
- Ciliates
- Tetrahymena
- Paramecium
- Oxytricha
- Euplotes
- Stylonichia
- Stentor
- Foraminifera
- Sarcodina (this may or may not be a natural group)
- Rhizopoda
- Entamoebidae (C-S now groups in Conosa with Mycetozoa: MBL 10-97)
- Entamoeba (secondarily amitochondrial: Clark 1995)
- Archamoebae (Formerly in the Archaezoa, but C-S now groups these with Entamoeba: MBL 10-97)
- Lobose amoebae (Jeff suggests 10-97 that Acanthamoeba (and hence lobose amoebae?) belongs with the Mycetozoa)
- Amoeba
- Acanthamoeba
- Hartmanella
- Actinopoda (Corliss would break this into Heliozoa+Radiozoa)
- Mycetozoa (=Myxomycota=Myxomycetes) (Sandie Baldauf's EF-1a analyses make this a monophyletic grp and put it at the base of A+F, many proteins genes certainly put them in the crown, tubulin and actin put Dictyostelium and Physarum together; Jeff suggests 10-97 that Acanthamoeba (and hence lobose amoebae?) belongs here, too; C-S puts these with Entamoebids in the Conosa: MBL 10-97)
- Plasmodial Slime Molds (=myxogastrids; amoeboflagellates, most forming large plasmodia with >10^4 synchronously dividing nuclei; e.g., Physarum)
- Cellular Slime Molds (amoebae, forming macroscopic, motile, differentiated slug-like things under conditions of nutrient starvation; e.g., Dictyostelium)
- Protostelid Slime Molds (mostly microscopic, showing a mixture of traits from the other two groups)
- Animals+Fungi+Choanoflagellates (C-S calls this opisthokonta, MBL 10-97)
- Animals
- Choanoflagellates (Inclusion here by Wainright 1993, FGMP mito prot trees, C-S MBL 10-97; note in this context that choanos have introns in their mtDNA, as do basal animal lineages and fungi; Sandie Baldauf 1998 SMBE indicated that EF-1a puts choanos closer to fungi than to animals)
- Fungi
- Microspora
Precise affinity -- or even inclusion here -- uncertain, though concensus is virtually complete by summer 1999 that they are fungi. IBC 1999: Patrick Keeling puts them in the eumycota, but from what Will told me about his (hsp?70?) analyses, they could well be chytrids... Placement here, instead of at the base of the euk trunk, based on:
presence of U2 (DiMaria 1996 NAR 24:515), U5 (unpub says Jeff), U6 (cited in C-S 1993 Microbio Rev but unpub?)
tubulin phylogeny: Edlin 1996 MPE 5:359, Keeling&Doolittle 1996 MBE13:1297
A+F signature insertion in EF-1a
lack of Paramomycin binding site (like A+F): Katiyar 1995 Gene 152:27
presence and phylogeny of fungal mito-type hsp70: Germot 1997 Mol Biochem Parasitology, 1998 MBE 95:683
...my memory is failing me...was it an aaRS?: Gogarten MBL 190-97
- Chytridiomycota (split from eumycota ~550 MYA: Berbee&Taylor 1993 Can J Bot)
- Blastocladiella
- Neocallimastix
- Eumycota
- Zygomycota
- Ascomycetes+Basidiomycetes
- Ascomycota
- Basidiomycota
- Schizosaccharomyces
- Chromista (this name from Corliss; essentially = Stramenopiles?; C-S calls this one of the big four Metakaryote groups, with A, F, P: MBL 10-97; tubular mitochondrial cristae (like alveolates), tripartite hairs on flagellum. This is one of the major monophyletic euk groups by OGMP multi-gene mtDNA analyses reported by Gertraude Berger at IBC 1999.)
- Cercozoa (I may be mis-representing this taxon, as I am assembling it from recollections of talks and posters...;C-S puts Chlorarachnion host with Filose amoebae in Cercozoa: MBL 10-97; Tubulin puts Cercomonas sister to Chlorarachnion host, consistent with Cercozoa: P. Keeling lab meeting 2-12-98; Ishida&C-S poster at 1998 SMBE shows tetrachotomy of (numerous) Chlorarchniophytes/Cercomonas/Paulinella/Euglypha based on nuclear SSU rRNA)
- Chlorarachniophytes (secondary green plastid plus NM; see Jeff and Chuck 1996 PNAS review)
- Cercomonas
- Filose amoebae (=testate amoebae?; are these really monophyletic?)
- Cryptophytes (tubulins say that sister to Cryptophytes is Goniomonas: P.Keeling, 2-12-98)
- Rhodomonas
- Cryptomonas (now called Guillardia: Douglas MBL 10-97; Secondary green, or more likely, red plastid plus NM -- see Jeff and Chuck 1996 PNAS review)
- Haptophytes (secondary red plastid)
- Heterokonts
- Chromophytes (secondary red plastid -- chlorophylls A&C)
- Xanthophyceae
- Phaeophyceae
- Costaria
- Laminaria (Kelp)
- Bacillariophyceae (Diatoms)
- Skeletonema
- Odontella
- Coscinodiscus
- Cyclotella
- Chrysophyceae
- Labyrinthulomycetes (placement here by Battacharya&Medlin, C-S 1993 Microbio Rev.)
- Blastocystis hominis (by Sogin&co: Silberman Nature 1996)
- Oomycetes (placement here by Battacharya, C-S 1993 Microbio Rev.)
- Achlya
- Phytophthora
- Lagenidium
- Plants (assuming a single primary endosymbiotic origin of plastids; for details see full page)
- Rhodophyta (primary red plastids: JDP 10-13-94)(Plastids with Chlorophyll A and phycobilins)
- Glaucocystophytes here?: Corliss 1994 -- Rhodophyta+Glaucocystophyta=Biliphyta (both have plastids with Chlorophyll A and phycobilins).
- Viridiplantae (primary green plastids: JDP 10-13-94)(Plastids with Chlorophylls A&B)...accepting that Land Plants are derived Charophytes makes "Viridiplantae" = "Chlorophytes"...
The page you are viewing, http://www.denison.edu/~kuhlman/WOL/eukaryote.html, was last modified on September 11, 2002.
This page is the creation and intellectual property of Peter L. Kuhlman.
If you have any comments or questions on this document, please send me e-mail!
.....go to my home page.....
.....go to the home page of the Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry at Denison University.....